Ma still moves the story forward.
Ma is the Japanese concept of stillness. In Spirited Away, minutes are given to Chihiro sitting in a train. Nothing in that time impacts the plot. Ma is negative space. In Seven Samurai, it is the quite before the battle. The viewer feels the village’s sense of isolation. Those minutes in Spirited Away also carried a theme of isolation, as well as growth and maturity. If we confuse story with plot, we’ll fail to see the relevance.
This confusion has haunted Hollywood throughout its history where studios demand scenes pivotal to the story be cut because they don’t advance the plot, and people who should know better don’t know the difference between plot and story.
The heart of the 2017 Wonder Woman movie was the title character charging across no man’s land in the middle of ongoing WWI trench warfare. Warner Bros executives wanted to cut the scene because they didn’t see how it advanced the “story.”
For Barbie, 2023, executives made the same mistake with the quiet scene of Barbie sitting on a bus bench next to an elderly lady and telling her she’s beautiful. The executives thought it useless because it didn’t advance the plot (which they called story). Greta Gerwig famously replied, “If we cut this scene, I don’t know what the movie is about.”
In The Wizard of Oz, 1939, the song “Over the Rainbow” is an emotional thesis statement that reveals Dorothy’s motivation and provides meaning to the story’s ultimate meaning that there’s no place like home. Executives cut the song from the movie, and the producers threatened to quit if it wasn’t restored. History repeated itself when Jeffrey Katzenberg demanded that “Part of Your World” be cut from The Little Mermaid, 1989.
In the climactic moments of The Godfather, mafia murders are intercut with the baptism scene, symbolizing the corruption of Michael’s soul and the very moment he claims to forsake Satan. The baptism didn’t impact the plot. Executives wanted it cut with a focus placed on the killings.
But here’s the thing. It’s not the executives’ fault. In 1927, in his book Aspects of the Novel, the great E. M. Forster explained plot and story in a way that I can never reconcile. I hate it. I’ve always hated it. Today, books on writing are heavily beholden to structure, and they constantly blur the distinction between plot and story. I blame Forster. I’ve never said this before but I’m saying it now. Forster got it wrong.
Forster said that story is a chronicle sequence of events. “The king died, and then the queen died.” The plot is the structured, causal relationship of those events. “The king died, and then the queen died of grief.” The instant I read that, I saw one central problem I’ve never been able to resolve. How can Forster make story smaller than plot?
Maybe he was thinking of the throughline or spine of the story. It’s the nugget that says what the story is about. The throughline for Barbie was: Stereotypical Barbie’s journey from a static, idealized doll into a complex, self-determined human who chooses the messy reality of mortality over manufactured perfection. That throughline explains the journey and acts as a guide for the plot, but there’s much more to the plot than can be captured so briefly. It attempts to capture the core of the story so that nothing strays too far, but we can’t reduce the idea of story to a throughline. Story is bigger than that. It’s bigger than plot.
That’s why, when we say that everything must move the story forward, we’re not necessarily talking about plot.

